Donald Trump pushes to bring back one of America’s most feared prisons, one of Alcatraz last surviving inmates has shared a chilling glimpse into what life was really like behind its concrete walls — and what made him feel utterly broken inside.
Former inmate Charlie Hopkins, now 93, has come forward with powerful memories of his time locked up on the isolated island prison. “It was the sound — or the silence, really — that made me feel like crying,” he told the BBC, recalling the eerie stillness that surrounded Alcatraz. With no radios and only a few books to distract them, inmates were left with their own thoughts and the occasional haunting sound of a ship’s whistle echoing through the fog.
Hopkins, who was transferred to Alcatraz in 1955 after trouble in other federal prisons, said the loneliness was unbearable. “That’s a lonely sound,” he said, comparing it to the mournful tones of a Hank Williams song. “There was nothing to do. You could walk back and forth in your cell or do push-ups. That was it.”
The notorious prison, sitting isolated on a 22-acre rock off San Francisco, shut its doors in 1963 — the same year Hopkins was released. Originally a military fortress, it was later turned into a federal penitentiary known for housing America’s most dangerous criminals. Now, decades later, it could see new life under a Trump administration plan.
In a recent Truth Social post, Trump declared his intent to “REBUILD, AND OPEN ALCATRAZ,” describing it as a solution to what he called a crisis of “vicious, violent, and repeat Criminal Offenders.” He envisions the revamped facility housing those he describes as “serial Offenders who spread filth, bloodshed, and mayhem on our streets.”
While it’s unclear if or when this plan might actually come to life, Trump insists he’s serious. “We will no longer be held hostage to criminals,” he wrote, announcing that the Bureau of Prisons, Department of Justice, FBI, and Homeland Security are being directed to reopen a “substantially enlarged and rebuilt ALCATRAZ.”
The announcement has reignited public interest in the infamous prison — and stirred deep memories for those like Hopkins, who lived through its harshest days. Would you want to see Alcatraz come back to life?


How about reopen the newly built prison in Appleton MN that was built & opened in 1992.
Closed in 2010. Literally unused – not even sure they ever had a prisoner housed there.