Less than a year ahead of the highly anticipated 2024 election, recent analysis by legal authority Norm Eisen, pollster Celinda Lake, and campaign researcher Anat Shenker-Osorio suggests that former President Donald Trump faces a substantial hurdle that could potentially imperil any lead he currently holds in polling data.
Despite Trump’s active engagement in early primary states, ongoing polls consistently portray a neck-and-neck contest between him and President Joe Biden, often with both candidates falling within the margin of error.
The pivotal factor potentially disregarded in these polls is the stance of voters if Trump were to face conviction by a jury, as highlighted by Eisen, Lake, and Shenker-Osorio. They underscore the continuing federal prosecution led by Special Counsel Jack Smith, alleging Trump’s involvement in a plot to overturn the 2020 election. The trial, initially scheduled for March 4, 2024, awaits appellate review, particularly concerning Trump’s presidential immunity.
Pending the federal appeals court’s decision, which is now before the Supreme Court, the case has been expedited, with a prospective hearing on January 9. The experts caution against drawing premature conclusions from polls this far from the election, as most voters typically engage more actively in the final months leading up to Election Day.
Recent polls indicate a discernible negative trend for Trump’s electoral prospects, particularly over the past six months. A hypothetical scenario depicted in a Wall Street Journal poll shows Trump leading Biden by four percentage points. However, a potential conviction could trigger a significant shift, resulting in a five-point swing that puts Biden in the lead at 47 percent to 46 percent.
Other surveys, like the Yahoo News-YouGov poll, suggest a seven-point swing. Additionally, in a December New York Times-Siena College poll, nearly a third of Republican primary voters express hesitation about Trump retaining the party’s nomination in case of a conviction, despite his primary win.
This trend is notably conspicuous in specific states such as Michigan and Georgia, where polls highlight a considerable portion of voters not only unwilling to vote for Trump if convicted but also advocating for his disqualification from the presidency.
The demographic most notably affected by a potential conviction seems to be young voters and independents, both exhibiting a clear shift away from supporting Trump if he were to be labeled a convicted felon. These insights indicate that Trump’s legal battles could wield substantial influence on voter sentiments in what is expected to be a closely contested election.
As Trump’s campaign machinery operates actively in multiple states and Biden’s campaign gains momentum, the shadow of these legal proceedings looms over the political landscape, poised to potentially reshape the dynamics of the upcoming 2024 presidential race.