Former President Donald Trump encountered another legal setback on May 14, 2024, when a New York appeals court upheld a gag order against him in his hush money criminal case. This decision, issued by Judge Juan Merchan, restricts Trump from publicly commenting on witnesses, prosecutors, court staff, or the judge’s family, although he is still permitted to criticize Judge Merchan and Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg.
Trump has vigorously opposed the gag order, arguing that it infringes on his First Amendment rights and limits his ability to counter political attacks from high-profile witnesses and others. The Hill reports that Trump maintains this order hampers his ability to defend himself publicly.
In their ruling, the five-judge panel affirmed Judge Merchan’s decision, stating, “Justice Merchan properly determined that the petitioner’s public statements posed a significant threat to the integrity of the testimony of witnesses and potential witnesses in this case.” They compared the gag order to a similar one imposed in Trump’s federal election interference case, which was also upheld by the District of Columbia U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
More Read
The panel highlighted the necessity of maintaining a trial environment free from fear or intimidation to ensure fair proceedings. Trump is currently facing 34 counts of falsifying business records related to an alleged repayment scheme involving his former fixer, Michael Cohen, who paid $130,000 to porn actor Stormy Daniels during the 2016 election to keep quiet about an alleged affair with Trump. Trump denies the affair, insists he committed no wrongdoing with the payments, and has pleaded not guilty.
Trump’s legal team has expressed frustration over Cohen’s public statements against Trump leading up to his testimony, arguing that Cohen’s comments have been inflammatory while Trump is restrained by the gag order. In response, Judge Merchan directed prosecutors to advise Cohen to refrain from making further public statements about the case.
Judge Merchan has found Trump in violation of the gag order ten times, each resulting in a $1,000 fine. He has warned that any future breaches could lead to jail time for Trump. This ongoing legal battle over the alleged hush money payments continues to add layers of complexity and tension to an already contentious case.
Trump’s efforts to defend his innocence face significant legal challenges, compounded by the constraints imposed by the court. As the legal proceedings unfold, each new development underscores the difficulties Trump encounters in navigating these judicial constraints while maintaining his public defense.
This case, along with other legal challenges Trump faces, is poised to significantly impact his public image and political aspirations, making his path forward increasingly challenging in the face of mounting legal hurdles.
