Misleading videos and false claims suggesting President Joe Biden aimlessly wandered off from the G7 conference last week continue to spread widely, despite numerous debunkings and fact-checks aiming to set the record straight.
These deceptive clips, which have garnered millions of views on X and other platforms, were flagged as “top stories” by Google, according to NBC News. The videos were also shared on TikTok and YouTube with minimal context, further spreading misinformation. Meta, the parent company of Instagram and Facebook, applied fact-checking labels to some posts, but not all, highlighting the challenge of managing misinformation during the 2024 election cycle.
Misleading Videos and Their Impact
President Joe Biden and other G7 leaders were attending a flag ceremony with paratroopers at Borgo Egnazia Golf Club San Domenico in Savelletri, Italy, on June 13. A video showed Biden walking toward a group of parachutists who had just landed, giving them two thumbs-up. However, conservative media outlets and the Republican National Committee (RNC) shared videos shot from angles that excluded the parachutists, creating the false narrative that Biden was wandering off aimlessly.
More Read
The Role of Tech Platforms and Partisan Media
The persistence of these misleading videos underscores the complex interaction between major tech platforms and partisan media. Hyperpartisan outlets repeatedly push misleading information, which motivated followers amplify. This overwhelms tech platforms, which struggle to correct the record swiftly enough, allowing false information to outpace fact-checking efforts.
Laura Edelson, a computer science professor at Northeastern University, noted that those behind these misleading claims benefit from tech companies’ cost-cutting measures. Companies like Google, Meta, and X have laid off many employees who worked on trust and safety teams, the core of efforts to limit misinformation. This leaves platforms relatively defenseless against partisan media pushing misleading claims.
Fact-Checking and Tech Platforms’ Response
Independent fact-checkers, including NBC News, PolitiFact, USA Today, and The Washington Post, have debunked the video. The White House condemned the misleading videos as lies spread by Rupert Murdoch’s media outlets. British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, who was near Biden, clarified that Biden was being polite to the skydivers.
Despite these fact-checks, misleading versions of the story remained prominent in Google’s search engine recommendations. Social media users have attempted to add context using X’s “community notes” feature, but many misleading posts remain uncorrected. The videos continued to receive millions of views on platforms like TikTok, Facebook, and YouTube, with thousands of engagements on Instagram.
Challenges of Enforcing Misinformation Policies
Although platforms have policies against misinformation, enforcing them remains a significant challenge. Some platforms applied fact-checking labels, but many misleading posts continued to spread widely without correction. Fox News, owned by Murdoch’s companies, claimed its programs aired the unedited footage of the president in Italy. Spokespeople for TikTok and Meta did not comment immediately, and other media companies involved did not respond to requests for comments.
This episode illustrates the dynamics of the new information ecosystem, where tech platforms hesitate to emphasize vetted information during an election year to avoid appearing partisan, while partisan operatives exploit this neutrality. As tech companies struggle with misinformation due to staff cuts and overwhelmed systems, the spread of misleading content continues to pose significant challenges in maintaining an informed public.
